Share your experience!
Why don't you set a limit and mobile data will be disabled when you cross that limit? Do you have auto updates all the time on google play?
I dont see a reason to replace your device. It doesn't seem faulty of the device. Like alex said, you should set a data limit. Also if you think the device is counting the dats used wrongly, try doing a software repair, it should smooth all things!
Have you sent and received a lot of MMS? (pictures or videos) not through whatsapp but through the messaging app?
go to settings > data usage
what has used up your data?
do you have a family plan?
Well,you can try. Also location and GPS use a lot of data.
But do you have a family plan and/or any dongle to have data on your tablet or computers etc?